Second opinion from a company doctor
A second opinion is a second, independent medical assessment by a company doctor from another organisation. The employee requests it when in doubt about the advice of their own company doctor, and the employer pays, as laid down in the Arbowet (Working Conditions Act). The assessment is advice to the first company doctor and helps move the reintegration forward when employer and employee are stuck.
(report included)
A selection of our satisfied clients














ZorgLogistics














FH Infra


Horecagroep Limburg






Gemu Mania
MMT Transport
Quantbox

Huizer Compliance
Second opinion from a company doctor: the short answers
Five questions employers ask us most often, with the answers.
Who pays for a second opinion?
The employer, even when the employee requests it. This is set out in the Arbowet.
Is a second opinion binding?
No. The first company doctor remains responsible and must give reasons if the assessment is not followed.
What does a second opinion cost?
Through Flexbedrijfsarts, from 325 euros excluding VAT, including the report. An overview of all company doctor costs is available in one place.
What is a second opinion?
A second, independent medical assessment by a company doctor from another organisation. The employee requests it; the employer pays.
What is the difference between a second opinion and a UWV expert opinion?
A UWV expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel) is requested from the UWV and concerns the reintegration. A second opinion is a second medical assessment by a company doctor.
The Gatekeeper Act process from week 1 to 104
Each step has a fixed week and a fixed owner. The highlighted step relates to this topic; the other steps link to their own explanations.
Situations that call for a second opinion
When there are doubts about the medical assessment or the advice of the first company doctor. When employee and employer disagree about the capacity for work or the scope for reintegration.
In long-term or complex sick leave cases where an independent second medical assessment is needed.
At the request of the employee, who is entitled under the Arbowet to a second opinion from another, independent company doctor (through the same or another health and safety service).
A second opinion step by step, from request to report
It starts with the employee. If the employee has doubts about the company doctor's advice, the employee asks that company doctor for a second opinion. No reason needs to be given, and the company doctor may only refuse on serious grounds, set out in writing. The company doctor then refers the employee to a company doctor from another health and safety service or from an independent pool. The basic contract between the employer and the health and safety service or company doctor specifies which one.
The second company doctor receives the file, speaks with the employee and writes a report. That report goes to the employee first and only reaches the first company doctor with the employee's consent. The first company doctor then decides whether to adjust the advice. If the first company doctor does not follow the assessment, they must explain why to employer and employee. The employer therefore receives no medical details, but does receive reasoned advice on the capacity for work and the reintegration.
Through Flexbedrijfsarts, the consultation is scheduled within a few working days of the request. The doctor carrying out the second opinion has had no previous involvement in the case.
1
Step 1
Request by the employee
To the employee's own company doctor, without giving a reason. Refusal is only possible on serious grounds, set out in writing.
2
Step 2
Referral
To a company doctor from another health and safety service or from an independent pool.
3
Step 3
Consultation and report
The second company doctor speaks with the employee. The report goes to the employee first.
4
Step 4
Decision by the first company doctor
Adjusts the advice or explains to employer and employee why not.
Who pays for a second opinion?
Under the Arbowet, the cost of a second opinion is borne by the employer, even if the employee requests it and even if the outcome is the same. The reasoning: the company doctor works for the employer, so the employee should not be charged for a check on that doctor's assessment. Through Flexbedrijfsarts, a second opinion costs from 325 euros excluding VAT, including the written report. The amount is confirmed in advance.
Compare that with the cost of a process that goes wrong. If the employee stays at home out of dissatisfaction or the reintegration stalls on a difference of opinion, an independent second opinion is the cheapest item in the file. At the WIA application, the UWV also prefers to see that a disagreement has been handled properly rather than ignored.
Not binding, but carries weight
A second opinion is advice to the first company doctor, not a ruling. The first company doctor remains responsible for supporting the employee and for advising the employer. In practice, the assessment carries considerable weight: if the first company doctor departs from it, that doctor must give reasons, and those reasons go into the file that the UWV assesses after two years.
The employer's obligations do not change during the second opinion. Sick pay (continued payment of wages) continues, the deadlines of the Gatekeeper Improvement Act (Wet verbetering poortwachter) keep running and the first company doctor's advice stands until that doctor changes it. So do not put the action plan or the evaluations on hold until the report is in.
During the second opinion
continues
Sick pay
Gatekeeper Improvement Act deadlines
The first company doctor's advice
Stands until that doctor changes it.
Action plan and evaluations
Do not put these on hold until the report is available.
Doubts on the employer's side: the employer's options
The right to a second opinion lies with the employee; the employer cannot request one. The employer has three other routes. The first is to talk to the company doctor directly: ask the doctor to explain the advice and to set out the capacity for work in specific hours and tasks. The second is a UWV expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel) if the disagreement is about reintegration: the employee's ability to work, the suitability of the work offered or the employee's efforts. The third is a different company doctor for the rest of the support, which can be arranged through us per consultation, without cancelling a contract.
If the doubt concerns the medical side, talk to the employee about requesting a second opinion themselves. Often the employee wants one too; the report helps both parties move forward.
Route 1
A conversation with the company doctor
Ask for an explanation, and for the capacity for work to be set out in hours and tasks.
Route 2
UWV expert opinion
If the disagreement is about reintegration.
Route 3
A different company doctor for the follow-up
Booked through us per consultation, without cancelling a contract.
Our second opinion doctors
What can the employer expect?
Always independent and objective
The doctor who carries out the second opinion is fully independent and has had no previous involvement in the file. The employer receives a fair, unbiased medical assessment.
Experienced in complex sick leave cases
Our doctors specialise in complex and long-term sick leave cases. They combine medical expertise with careful judgement, aimed at workable solutions.
Quick turnaround, clear outcome
We schedule the consultation within a few working days. The employer receives clear advice, substantiated in writing, that can be used straight away in the rest of the reintegration process.
The systems we work with
We work with secure digital systems such as Planningsagenda for fast scheduling and MediSync for professional reporting. This keeps everything clear and the second opinion running smoothly.
Frequently asked questions
Frequently asked questions about the second opinion
Who pays for the second opinion?
The employer. The Arbowet (Working Conditions Act) places the costs with the employer, even when the employee requests the second opinion. The employee pays nothing and does not need to give reasons for the request.
Is the outcome of the second opinion binding?
No. The second company doctor gives an independent medical assessment, but the first company doctor remains responsible for the advice to the employer. If the first doctor does not adopt the assessment, that doctor must explain why.
What is the difference between a second opinion and a UWV expert opinion?
A second opinion is a second medical assessment by a different company doctor, paid for by the employer. A UWV expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel) is requested from the UWV and deals with one of two questions: was the employee rightly reported sick, or are employer and employee doing enough for reintegration? That opinion carries a lot of weight if the matter ends up in proceedings.
Can the company doctor refuse a second opinion?
Only on compelling grounds, which the company doctor must substantiate. In all other cases, the employee's request must be granted. This is laid down in the Arbowet.
What does a second opinion through Flexbedrijfsarts cost?
From 325 euros, including the report. The rate is confirmed in advance, so the employer faces no surprises.
How quickly is a second opinion arranged?
We schedule the consultation within a few working days. Written, substantiated advice follows, which the employer can use straight away in the reintegration process.
What can an employer do in a disagreement with the company doctor?
An employee can ask for a second opinion from a company doctor outside the organisation. That right is laid down in the Arbowet and the employer pays. If the disagreement is about reintegration rather than the medical assessment, a UWV expert opinion is the appropriate route. The two can run side by side.
Can an employer request a second opinion?
The right to a second opinion lies with the employee. The employer can, however, request a UWV expert opinion, or ask its own company doctor to review the advice. If the employer has doubts about the quality of the support, call us; a different conversation is often more useful than a second assessment.
Request a second opinion
An independent medical assessment within 5 working days
Further reading
Is the employer doubting the person who gave the assessment rather than the assessment itself? Read about the difference between an arbo doctor and a company doctor. Those pages also explain who may sign the problem analysis and how the employer can engage a company doctor directly.