For employers
Doubts about sick leave
If an employer doubts that an employee is really ill, the employer does not refuse the sick report and does not judge it personally either. The company doctor (occupational physician) assesses if the employee is unfit for work. If the doctor concludes that the employee can work and the employee still stays away, the absence is at the employee's own risk and the right to wages for those days lapses. If employer and employee disagree, a UWV expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel) can follow.
Company doctor
assesses if the employee is ill
419 euros
urgent consultation when a quick answer is needed, excluding VAT
2 to 3 weeks
indicative lead time for a UWV expert opinion
In writing
a warning comes first, before wages stop
A selection of our satisfied clients














ZorgLogistics














FH Infra


Horecagroep Limburg






Gemu Mania
MMT Transport
Quantbox

Huizer Compliance
Doubts about a sick report: the short answers
Who assesses whether an employee is really ill?
The company doctor. The employer accepts the sick report and has the company doctor assess whether the employee is unfit for work; refusing the report or stopping wages unilaterally does not hold up.
When in doubt, may an employer check personally if an employee is ill?
No. Under the AVG (GDPR), health data is special category personal data. The employer may not ask about the symptoms, may not carry out checks personally and may not record anything medical. Only the company doctor assesses incapacity for work, and the employer hears from the doctor what is needed for the work.
What does an employer do if an employee calls in sick but does not seem ill?
Avoid a discussion and ask the company doctor to assess the employee at short notice, sharing the context the employer has but without medical questions. The company doctor's assessment determines the next step.
May an employer withhold wages when there are doubts about an illness?
Not on the basis of doubt alone. Wages can only be stopped or suspended if the company doctor concludes that the employee can work and the employee still stays away, or if the employee does not comply with the sickness monitoring rules.
What if employer and employee disagree about the sick report?
Then either of them can request an expert opinion from the UWV. The employee can also ask another company doctor for a second opinion.
Can an unjustified sick report lead to dismissal?
Only in serious cases, for example proven deception, and with solid grounds. A single doubtful sick report is not enough.
Can an employer refuse a sick report?
No. An employer cannot refuse a sick report and does not assess whether someone is ill. That assessment lies with the company doctor, who can speak to and examine the employee. An employer who starts checking for themselves or refuses the sick report anyway puts itself at a legal disadvantage.
If the company doctor reaches an assessment that the employer or the employee disagrees with, the UWV can give an expert opinion. The employee can also ask another company doctor for a second opinion.
The division of roles
Employer
Accepts the sick report, arranges the work and the contact, and calls in the company doctor in case of doubt.
Company doctor
Assesses if the employee is unfit for work and advises on work, without giving the employer a diagnosis.
UWV
Gives an expert opinion on request when employer and employee disagree.
From doubt to clarity
1
Accept the sick report
No discussion about whether the employee is really ill; the usual questions about duration and availability are fine.
2
Call in the company doctor
At short notice, with the employer's context, such as a pattern or a conflict, without medical questions.
3
Assessment by the company doctor
Unfit for work, partially employable or able to work.
4
Record the agreements
On the return to work, adapted work or the next step in the support.
5
In case of disagreement
A UWV expert opinion, or a second opinion at the employee's request.
Steps when there are doubts about a sick report
Doubt often arises from a pattern, such as sick reports around the weekend, or from a conflict or a dismissal meeting shortly before the sick report. That context is useful to the company doctor, as long as the employer does not ask medical questions.
The sooner the company doctor sees the employee, the sooner there is clarity. An urgent consultation makes that possible. If the employee turns out not to be ill, agreements on the return to work follow. If a conflict turns out to be behind the sick report, the company doctor can advise a time-out or mediation.
Wages in case of doubt or an unjustified sick report
Doubt alone is no reason to stop wages. Wages continue to be paid until the company doctor has given an assessment or the employee fails to keep to the agreements.
Every sanction on wages starts with a written warning that states what the employee must do. Without that step, a sanction usually does not hold up in court.
Situation and consequence for wages
Doubt only, no assessment yet
Continue paying wages
Call in the company doctor
Company doctor: able to work, employee stays away
No wages for those days
Assessment by the company doctor, recorded in writing
Cannot be reached or did not attend the appointment with the company doctor
Wages suspended, paid later
Sickness monitoring rules, written warning
Suitable work refused or recovery obstructed
Wage stop
Written warning
Pattern
Frequently ill for short periods
Record the dates and duration, hold a conversation about the pattern and the consequences for the work, and involve the company doctor if there may be an underlying cause.
Conflict
Ill after a conflict or a dismissal meeting
The company doctor assesses if it is a matter of illness or conflict; in the case of a conflict without illness, a time-out of no more than two weeks and mediation if necessary.
A pattern or a conflict behind the sick report
Doubts about a sick report are often linked to something else. Repeated short sick reports point to a pattern, which calls for a conversation and an examination by the company doctor into a possible cause.
If the sick report follows a conflict or a dismissal meeting, the company doctor assesses if there is illness or a situation in which the conflict temporarily prevents the employee from working. In the latter case, the company doctor can advise a time-out of one to no more than two weeks, followed by mediation.
Our rates
Individual rates, excluding VAT. No subscription and no fee per employee.
Urgent consultation
when it is urgent
419 euros
First consultation with a company doctor
assessment of the capacity for work and advice
299 euros
Request for a UWV expert opinion (deskundigenoordeel)
excluding 400 euros in UWV fees
450 euros
Case management meeting after a sick report
by the case manager
179 euros
Frequently asked questions
Questions about doubts over a sick report
What if an employee calls in sick but is not ill?
Then the company doctor assesses this. If the doctor concludes that the employee can work, the employee is expected to return to work. If the employee still stays away, the right to wages for those days lapses, after a written warning.
When may an employer withhold wages during sick leave?
If the employee does not comply with the sickness monitoring rules (suspension), if the employee fails to cooperate with reintegration without good reason or refuses suitable work (wage stop), or if the company doctor concludes that the employee can work and the employee still stays away. Always after a written warning.
May an employer check if an employee is really ill?
Not personally. The employer can ask the company doctor or the health and safety service to assess this. The employer does not ask medical questions.
May an employee report sick after a dismissal meeting or a conflict?
Yes, reporting sick is always possible. The company doctor assesses if there is illness or a conflict that temporarily prevents the employee from working, and advises on the next step.
What is a UWV expert opinion when there are doubts about an illness?
An independent assessment by the UWV when employer and employee disagree, for example on the employee's incapacity for work. The UWV charges the employer 400 euros for this; through Flexbedrijfsarts, the application costs 450 euros, excluding VAT.
Can an employee request a second opinion?
Yes. If the employee disagrees with the company doctor's assessment, the employee can ask another company doctor for a second opinion.
Can an unjustified sick report be grounds for summary dismissal?
In serious cases, for example if it is established that the employee deliberately misled the employer. That requires solid grounds; in case of doubt, the company doctor's assessment is the first step.
May an employer hire a private investigator?
Only in the case of a concrete and serious suspicion, and within strict privacy rules. In most cases, an assessment by the company doctor provides clarity faster and more carefully.
What does an urgent consultation cost when there are doubts about a sick report?
At Flexbedrijfsarts, an urgent consultation costs 419 euros and a first consultation 299 euros, excluding VAT. No subscription.
May an employee on sick leave work elsewhere?
Working elsewhere is not automatically prohibited. If that work obstructs or delays recovery, the right to wages lapses, and income from work that could have been done during the employee's own working hours is offset. Report what is known to the company doctor, who reassesses the capacity for work. Summary dismissal usually only holds up if it is established that recovery has been harmed or that the employee has misled the employer.
What does an employer do if an employee on sick leave cannot be reached?
The employer may ask for a telephone number and the address where the employee is staying while ill. If the employee does not comply with the written sickness monitoring rules, the employer can suspend wages, and must inform the employee of this without delay. The wages are paid in arrears as soon as the employee complies with the agreements again.
May an employee demand that all contact goes through the company doctor?
That depends on the company doctor's advice. If the doctor advises limiting contact with the employer temporarily, the employer follows that advice. Without such advice, contact about the work and the return to work remains possible.
What happens if an employer does not accept a sick report?
The employee remains on sick leave and keeps the right to continued payment of wages. If the employer stops wages without an assessment by the company doctor, the employee can claim those wages, with the statutory increase and interest. In case of doubt, have the company doctor assess at short notice whether the employee can work.
Last updated on 3 October 2026.
Further reading
More on illness and sick leave: employee on sick leave, frequent absence, workplace mediation, UWV expert opinion and sick pay, or see the cost of a company doctor. See also the powers of the company doctor, a workplace conflict with a sick report, wage stop and wage suspension, an employee on sick leave who cannot be reached, working elsewhere during sick leave, urgent consultation, what a company doctor does and a company doctor in a workplace conflict.
Have doubts about a sick report assessed
Describe the situation. On working days we call back within 2 hours, and a company doctor is assigned within 24 hours.